Comparisons
Comparisons
Arguments about what is better almost always come down to the question "better for what?". Some headphones are handy on the underground, others at home during a long film; a speaker is great at a picnic but annoys other passengers on a train. In the tables below we compare not models but types of device and ways of connecting, so you can more easily work out what suits your own habits.
The best headphones are the ones you can comfortably wear for as long as you usually listen.
How to read the tables: they describe general patterns. A particular device may differ from the typical one, so check its description and manual.
In-ear vs on-ear vs over-ear
| Criterion | In-ear | On-ear | Over-ear |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fit | Sit in the ear canal or at its entrance | Rest on the ears, held in place by a headband | Fully surround the ears with soft cups |
| Pros | Light, fit in a pocket together with the case | Don't press into the ear, easy to take off | Comfortable for long listening at home, good at shutting out noise |
| Cons | Easy to lose, ear tips need to be the right size | Can press on the ears over time and leak sound | Bulky, hot to wear in summer |
| Who they suit | People who walk a lot and use public transport | People who find in-ears uncomfortable and big headphones heavy | People who listen or watch films for a long time in one place |
Wired vs wireless
| Criterion | Wired | Wireless |
|---|---|---|
| Connection | Plug in and the sound starts straight away | Pair once, then they connect by themselves |
| Latency | Practically unnoticeable, handy for games and editing | A slight delay that can be felt in games |
| Power | No charging needed | You need to keep an eye on the headphones' and case's charge |
| Freedom | The cable catches on clothes and restricts movement | You can walk away from the phone, but the signal weakens through walls |
| Who they suit | People who value predictability and don't want to think about charging | People who move a lot and hate getting tangled in cables |
Headphones vs portable speaker
| Criterion | Headphones | Portable speaker |
|---|---|---|
| Who hears it | Only you | Everyone nearby |
| Where they work well | On public transport, in the office, at home at night | In the kitchen, in the garden, with a small group of friends |
| Calls | Easy to talk, the microphone is closer to your face | Fine for speakerphone calls in a quiet room |
| Keep in mind | Don't listen loudly for long and stay able to hear the street | Don't disturb the neighbours, and don't leave it in the rain or the sun |
How to choose without second-guessing
Think about where you listen most often. If it is on the move, light wireless earbuds win. If it is long evenings at home, large headphones are more comfortable. If several people need to hear the sound at once, a speaker comes to the rescue.
Many people are happy with a combination: wireless earbuds for outdoors and wired headphones or a speaker for home. That way you don't have to expect one device to do everything.
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: first connection, two devices at once, sound in videos and games, the microphone on calls, caring for ear tips. Plus our article catalogue.
- Tools
The paired devices list, pairing mode, the charging case, sound settings, the volume warning and finding a lost earbud.
- Problems
Headphones not showing up, sound dropping out or lagging, only one earbud playing, callers struggling to hear you, battery draining too fast.
- Glossary
Pairing, multipoint, codec, latency, noise cancelling, transparency mode, ear tips and cushions and other terms, in plain language.
- Questions
Answers about the guide, connecting and sound quality, the battery and using wireless headphones and speakers safely.
Sources
- Headphone and speaker manufacturers' instructions (in general terms)
- The guide's editorial material
This guide describes wireless audio in general terms and reflects the editors' view as of the date it was prepared. Headphones and speakers are controlled in different ways: some with a button, some with a touch, and settings on phones and computers are not always named the same. If your device's manual says otherwise, follow the manual.